Chicago is a paradise for sugar lovers, offering everything from gourmet chocolates to innovative desserts that push the boundaries of creativity. However, with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to find the best sweet spots that truly deliver a memorable experience. Whether you’re a local looking to satisfy your sweet tooth or a tourist searching for must-try dessert destinations, this guide will help you discover the crème de la crème of Chicago’s dessert scene. From bakeries with iconic pastries to hidden gems serving unique confections, we’ll cover the best places to indulge, along with insider tips to make your dessert journey unforgettable.
In this guide, you’ll find step-by-step recommendations to navigate Chicago’s sweetest offerings. We’ll highlight renowned establishments, lesser-known treasures, and even some tips for avoiding common pitfalls (like long waits or sold-out specialties). Plus, if you’re unsure where to start, our Quick Reference section will give you instant ideas for your sugar-filled adventure. Let’s dive in and explore the irresistible sweet spots that every sugar lover needs to know in Chicago!
Quick Reference
- Start with a visit to Mindy’s Bakery for their famous gooey cinnamon rolls.
- Pre-order dessert specials at hotspots like Kasama to skip long lines.
- Avoid visiting popular dessert shops during peak hours (weekend afternoons) to ensure availability.
1. Iconic Dessert Destinations You Can’t Miss
Chicago is home to some legendary dessert spots that have become institutions in the city. These are the places that every sugar lover should experience at least once. Here are a few must-visit destinations and what makes them special:
Mindy’s Bakery
Mindy’s Bakery in Bucktown is a haven for pastry lovers. Their cinnamon rolls are the stuff of legend—ooey, gooey, and perfectly spiced. The bakery also offers a rotating menu of seasonal items, so there’s always something new to try. Arrive early because popular items sell out quickly!
Pro Tip: Mindy’s also has amazing savory options, so consider making it a brunch stop to enjoy both sweet and savory treats.
Margie’s Candies
Step back in time at Margie’s Candies, a Chicago institution since 1921. Known for their decadent sundaes served in silver bowls, this retro shop is perfect for a nostalgic dessert experience. Choose from a variety of flavors, and don’t miss their homemade hot fudge topping.
Pro Tip: Margie’s has two locations, but the original on Western Ave offers the full vintage experience.
Kasama
This Michelin-starred Filipino restaurant is not just about savory dishes—it has a dessert program that’s equally impressive. Their ube-based desserts, like the ube and coconut pie, are a must-try for adventurous eaters. Kasama is perfect for those looking to explore unique flavors beyond traditional sweets.
Pro Tip: Kasama’s desserts often sell out, so it’s best to pre-order online if possible.
2. Hidden Gems for Unique Sweet Treats
While Chicago’s big-name dessert destinations are worth the hype, the city also boasts a wealth of hidden gems where you can find one-of-a-kind confections. Here are some lesser-known spots that deserve a place on your dessert bucket list:
Pretty Cool Ice Cream
Located in Logan Square, Pretty Cool Ice Cream specializes in artisan ice cream bars in creative flavors like “Cereal Milk Crunch” and “Thai Iced Tea.” Their bars are not only delicious but also Instagram-worthy, making them a hit with locals and visitors alike.
Pro Tip: The menu changes seasonally, so be sure to check out their latest creations when you visit.
Aya Pastry
Aya Pastry is a bakery that combines artistic presentation with incredible flavors. Their desserts often feature intricate designs, such as their signature entremets (layered mousse cakes). It’s the perfect spot for a treat that’s as beautiful as it is delicious.
Pro Tip: Aya Pastry also supplies desserts to several high-end restaurants in Chicago, so you may have already tasted their creations without realizing it!
XO Marshmallow
If you think marshmallows are boring, XO Marshmallow will change your mind. This boutique specializes in gourmet marshmallows in flavors like champagne, lavender honey, and birthday cake. They also offer s’mores kits and other fun treats for marshmallow enthusiasts.
Pro Tip: XO Marshmallow hosts occasional workshops where you can learn to make your own marshmallows—perfect for a unique and sweet experience!
3. Tips for Planning Your Sweet Tour
Embarking on a dessert tour across Chicago requires a bit of strategy to make the most of your time and appetite. Here are some practical tips to ensure a smooth and enjoyable experience:
Plan Your Route
Chicago is a sprawling city, so it’s important to group your dessert stops by neighborhood. For example, you can explore Lincoln Park one day and hit up Logan Square another. This will save you time and transportation costs.
Check Hours and Availability
Many dessert spots have limited hours or sell out of popular items quickly. Always check their website or social media for up-to-date information before heading out. Some places, like Kasama, offer pre-order options to guarantee your treats.
Share to Maximize Variety
Bring a friend or two and share desserts at each stop. This way, you can try more items without getting too full. Most dessert portions in Chicago are generous, so sharing is both practical and fun.
Bring a Cooler for Takeout
If you’re planning to visit multiple spots in one day, consider bringing a small cooler to keep your takeout items fresh. This is especially useful for ice cream or other perishable treats.
Go Off-Peak
Weekend afternoons tend to be the busiest times for popular dessert spots. Visit during weekdays or earlier in the day to avoid crowds and ensure the best selection.
What’s the best time to visit Chicago’s dessert spots?
The best time to visit is during off-peak hours, such as weekday mornings or early afternoons. This helps you avoid long lines and ensures that popular items are still available.
Are there vegan or gluten-free dessert options in Chicago?
Yes, many dessert spots in Chicago offer vegan and gluten-free options. For example, Pretty Cool Ice Cream has dairy-free bars, and Mindy’s Bakery often features gluten-free pastries.
Can I bring desserts home from these spots?
Absolutely! Many dessert shops offer takeout-friendly packaging. Bring a small cooler if you’re purchasing perishable items like ice cream or mousse cakes to keep them fresh during transport.
Exploring Chicago’s dessert scene is a delicious adventure that every sugar lover should embark on. Whether you’re diving into a classic sundae at Margie’s Candies or trying a creative ice cream bar at Pretty Cool Ice Cream, the city offers endless options to satisfy your sweet tooth. With this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to discover the best sweet spots and make the most of your dessert journey. Happy indulging!